Ironweed by William Kennedy (1983)

Ironweed by William Kennedy (1983)Francis Phelan is on the bum. In 1938, in Albany, New York, he wanders from place to place seeking nourishment and appeasement for the heavy guilts that plague him. The novel takes its title from the ironweed plant; a tough, resilient wildflower which significantly resembles the necessary mental and physical strength drawn upon by the desperately impoverished characters of William Kennedy’s Ironweed. Francis is perpetually on the run from his outbursts of lethal violence, running from family responsibilities and work and always toward drink. He returns to Albany, with his lady friend Helen and attempts to reconcile himself with his actions of the past.

Bodies in alleys, bodies in gutters, bodies anywhere, were part of his eternal landscape: a physical litany of the dead.

While working in a cemetery to cover outstanding law debts, Francis Phelan comes across his son’s grave – a son who at the age of 13 days, Francis accidentally dropped and killed. The cemetery is populated with the dead; not only in their graves but as lucid figures surrounding Francis. Gerald, his son, takes on a godlike presence in this world of the dead. Outside of the cemetery, these dead characters continue to figure prominently around Francis, he sees them, he speaks to them, he reflects on their demise and their lives, and his part in them. It is possible that these conversations and memories of the dearly departed are the rampant imagination and senseless rambling of a drunk, or the spectres of mental illness, or more likely, simply a literary device for the past and guilt. Nonetheless, these ghosts play such an integral role as Francis comes to terms with his often violent past.

Only the light had changed, brighter now, and with it grew Francis’s hatred of all fantasy, all insubstantiality. I am sick of you all, was his thought. I am sick of imagining what you became, what I might have become if I’d lived among you. I am sick of your melancholy histories, your sentimental pieties, you goddamned unchanging faces. I’d rather be dyin’ in the weeds than standin’ here lookin’ at you pinin’ away, like the dyin’ Jesus pinin’ for an end to it when he knew every stinkin’ thing that was gonna happen not only to himself but to everybody around him, and to all those that wasn’t even born yet. You ain’t nothin’ more than a photograph, you goddamn spooks. You ain’t real and I ain’t gonna be at your beck and call no more.
You’re all dead, and if you ain’t, you oughta be.
I’m the one is livin’. I’m the one puts you on the map.

The living characters equally occupy a hinterland between life and death. Life on the streets means existing inbetween human and animal nature. For the most part, the dead are more alive and influential than the living; the living and their dreams just as dead as those in buried in the ground. Take Oscar, an old bartender friend of Francis’:

And further, the attention that the bums, the swells, the waiters, were giving the man, proved that this drunk was not dead, not dying, but living an epilogue to a notable life. And yet, and yet … here he was, disguised behind a mustache, another cripple, his ancient, weary eyes revealing to Francis the scars of a blood brother, a man for whom life had been a promise unkept in spite of great success, a promise now and forever unkeepable. The man was singing a song that had grown old not from time but from wear. The song is frayed. The song is worn out.

Or Helen, constantly caught in a state between sleep and waking, until she too joins the legion of the dead:

What for weeks she had achieved in her time of rest was only an illustrated wakefulness that hovered at the edge of dream: angels rejoicing, multitudes kneeling before the Lamb, worms all, creating a great butterfly of angelic hair, Helen’s joyous vision.

After drifting back toward the family he abandoned, Francis begins to see himself as something of a warrior. He learns that his guilt is the only thing which is undeniably his, acting as his driving force, a necessity: his way of paying penitence for his mistakes was to avoid facing up to the responsibility of his actions. The ending seems overly sentimental, compared to the grime and desperation of most of the novel. Francis returns to the family, and they accept him with little reluctance, though this ending is not without sadness, as in doing so he loses the beautifully drawn Helen to death and his whimsical companion Rudy to violent thugs. The saccharine ending  jars somewhat with the aimless contemplative meanderings written in lyrical and original prose that came before, but does not completely undermine the powerful language, imagery and characters of Francis’s life lived on the run.

[A film version starring Jack Nicholson, Meryl Streep and Tom Waits was released in 1987. The trailer, and the full film are available to watch on YouTube.]

Fiesta: The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway (1926)

Fiesta: The Sun Also Rises by Ernest Hemingway (1926)I read The Old Man and the Sea for the first time last year and I was not exactly what you would call an instant Hemingway convert. “JUST THROW THE EFFING FISH BACK!” yelled the heathen literal reader within. However, I am a creature of persistence and so I picked up Ernest Hemingway’s Fiesta or, The Sun Also Rises. While I enjoyed it on the basic narrative level, I also wish it had delved deeper into the emotional complexities of these characters lives and world, rather than just making them seem like drunken animals. The prose is characteristically spare, devoid of all exposition or reflective passages – what happens simply happens.

It was like certain dinners I remember from the war. There was much wine, an ignored tension, and a feeling of things coming that you could not prevent happening. Under the wine I lost the disgusted feeling and was happy. It seemed they were all such nice people.

Jake Barnes is living in Paris, impotent because of a vague war injury, and very much in love with the engaged Lady Brett Ashley. Jake discovers that Brett has also been having an affair with his friend Robert Cohn, and the tensions build on a trip to Pamplona where Jake, Brett, Robert, Brett’s fiancee Michael and Jake’s friend Bill travel to for the annual bullfighting fiesta. Cohn’s obsession with Brett grows, he cannot bear to be apart from her – frustrating not only Michael, but Jake and Brett as well. When Brett begins an affair with a young bullfighter Pedro Romero, jealousies between the men intensify and they resolve it in the way that men do: with some awkward, drunken fisticuffs. The novel ends in the aftermath of the fiesta, as Brett and Jake explore Madrid and she tells him that the two of them could have been good together. Jake’s great response to this is: “Isn’t it pretty to think so?” In a line, summing up the exact pain and beauty of unrequited, impossible love.

It was a good morning, there were high white clouds above the mountains. It hadrained a little in the night and it was fresh and cool on the plateau, and there was a wonderful view. We all felt good and we felt healthy, and I felt quite friendly to Cohn. You could not be upset about anything on a day like that.
That was the last day before the fiesta.

The vagueness surrounding the war and how it has affected these characters is intriguing – what we assume to be a monumental event in their lives is given very little thought or reflection. Somehow, through Jake’s impotency through war injury, and the complete inability for these men to comprehend their situations through anything but violence and possession, Hemingway seems to be suggesting the war has altered the American understanding of masculinity, how men see themselves in relation to the world and to women. The bullfights and the seven day fiesta atmosphere act as a sometimes distracting backdrop to these concerns, but at the same time heightening the particular tensions between the friends. The intensity and bloodiness of the bullfight action disturbingly mirrors the intricacies of human affairs.

Hemingway manages to make the bloody sport – the bullfights, not the affairs – seem a graceful art, and it is here that the writing shows the most compassion and energy. While Hemingway’s sparse style doesn’t instantly appeal to me, after having read The Sun Also Rises and enjoying it on a narrative level, I am now more inclined to pick up another of his novels.

Book Loot: Week Ending 28th March, 2010

Portrait Fille by Tamara de LempickaSincerest apologies for my unexpected week long absence from the world of book blogging, but sometimes music, friends and adventure are necessary diversions for maintaining sanity. Reviews will resume as usual from Wednesday. I went to Sydney during the week to see one of my favourite bands play live (and saw them again just a few days later in Melbourne.), hung out in the city for a few days, very maturely and joyously jumped on the hotel bed to pop music, hugged a superhero, got drunk with a British tourist, went book shopping:

A loot which did not interfere with my baggage limits, thank goodness. My favourite place in all of Sydney would have to be Kinokuniya, which had the most diverse range of books I have ever seen in a store. I said to my traveling companion Matt, “I hope you don’t get bored waiting around for me” but it turned out that he was just as enraptured by the store as I was. Later that evening, after our minds were blown by the experience of seeing Brand New live again, in a new city, new setlists, right up the front, sweaty, dancing and screaming; we agreed to get some food and end the night there. We were in bed before midnight, each of us reading our new books by lamplight like some oddball married couple, which was a little bit cute.

It was TOTALLY worth traveling all that way to see the band, such an intense live show and it strangely and inexplicably felt like closure and a new beginning at the same time. Not just garden variety closure, but boarding the windows, bolting the door shut, throwing away the keys to the locks, digging a moat around it, throwing a couple of nasty beasts into the moat, and blowing up the bridge to prevent anything from that part of the past returning. All that just from seeing a band! It feels like a pretty miraculous and exciting place to be.

[Image: Portrait Fille by Tamara de Lempicka]

Aesop’s Fables (5th Century BC)

Aesop: The Complete Fables (c. 5th century BC)It’s quite strange and revealing that although I’d never read Aesop’s Fables before now, so many of them have become so ingrained into the cultural consciousness to the point of complete saturation. It’s possible that they may had been read to me as a child, whether through adaptations or child-friendly renditions, but there is an unsettling viciousness about some of these fables. Beyond those of quiet platitudes about wits over strength/beauty, of good over evil, of truth over lies, there are fables here which highlight an essential absurdity or meaninglessness about our lives. Which is always somewhat difficult to stomach, isn’t it? One minute you are catching up on your Greek classic literature on the bus and the next a bout of existential angst about meaning and truth, and all this from something that has, in obviously sanitized versions, become basic storytelling rites and moral teachings for children?

Still, there is much to delight in here. Whether it is the fables of vengeful and spiteful gods who rule according to whim, or grotesquely comic tales of violence upon frogs (there really is a lot of murdered frogs in here), or just simply illustrative moral tales, the fables are worth revisiting. The genuine understanding of human behaviour evident remains relevant. There’s not much else to say really, is there? So, instead, here are some of my favourite fables from this collection.

The Ox and the Frog: Two little frogs were playing about at the edge of a pool when an Ox came down to the water to drink, and by accident trod on one of them and crushed the life out of him. When the old frog missed him, she asked his brother where he was. “He is dead, mother,” said the little frog; “an enormous big creature with four legs came to our pool this morning and trampled him down in the mud.” “Enormous, was he? Was he as big as this?” said the frog, puffing herself out to look as big as possible. “Oh! yes, much bigger,” was the answer. The frog puffed herself out still more. “Was he as big as this?” said she. “Oh! yes, yes, mother, MUCH bigger.” said the little frog. And yet again she puffed and puffed herself out till she was almost as round as a ball. “As big as…?” she began — but then she burst.

The Wasp and the Snake: A Wasp settled on the head of a Snake, and not only stung him several times, but clung obstinately to the head of his victim. Maddened with pain the Snake tried every means he could think of to get rid of the creature, but without success. At last he became desperate, and crying, “kill you I will, even at the cost of my own life,” he laid his head with the Wasp on it under the wheel of a passing wagon, and they both perished together.

Prometheus and the Making of Man: At the bidding of Jupiter, Prometheus set about the creation of Man and the other animals. Jupiter, seeing that mankind, the only rational creatures, were far outnumbered by the irrational beasts, bade him redress the balance by turning some of the latter into men. Prometheus did as he was bid, and this is the reason why some people have the forms of men, but the souls of beasts.

Demades and His Fable: Demades the orator was once speaking in the Assembly at Athens; but the people were very inattentive to what he was saying, so he stopped and said “Gentlemen, I should like to tell you one of Aesop’s fables.” This made every one listen intently. Then Demades began: “Demeter, a Swallow, and an Eel were once travelling together, and came to a river without a bridge: the Swallow flew over it, and the Eel swam across”; and then he stopped. “What happened to Demeter?” cried several people in the audience. “Demeter,” he replied, “is very angry with you for listening to fables when you ought to be minding public business.”

Book Loot: Week Ending 21st March, 2010

Girl Reading by Charles Edward Perugini, 1879

Well, I’ve finished reading all of John Green‘s novels and so now it’s on to the next author as part of my comprehensive reading quest, and, oh! look what arrived in the mail this week. The first volume of William Faulkner’s novels from 1926-1929, Soldiers’ Pay, Mosquitoes, Flags in the Dust (previously published in a heavily edited form as Sartoris) and The Sound and the Fury. I really love the Library of America collections, even if the design is rather outwardly plain. They’re of a good, sturdy size, and thorough collections of essential authors. Positively drool-worthy.

Although, it is probably too heavy going and unwieldy for holiday reading for my brief trip to Sydney this week, so I might leave ol’ Willy behind and take Pop: Truth and Power at the Coca-Cola Company by Constance Hays. Or maybe Winter Under Water?  Other than seeing one of my favourite bands, Brand New – the original intent for the trip, a sort of reward for surviving a very average 2009 – I plan to scout out the best of Sydney’s bookstores. Excess luggage charges ahoy!

Image credit: Girl Reading by Charles Edward Perugini, 1879

Paper Towns by John Green (2008)

Paper Towns by John Green (2008)Finally! I sped through Paper Towns over the course of roughly twenty four hours; staying up until 2am (hey, that’s pretty late for me now) and finishing it off in one sitting the next day. The mystery surrounding the narrative of Margo Roth Spiegelman demands the readers attention. I’ve made it pretty clear in my reviews of both Looking for Alaska and An Abundance of Katherines that the female characters in John Green‘s young adult fiction come across as mere devices for the enlightenment of the male characters, but in Paper Towns Green seems to be critiquing that approach, or at least questioning the validity of it.

In Paper Towns, John Green again creates quirky outsiders just on the edge of full-blown geekery; I often wonder how much of these male lead characters are evidence of Green’s own idiosyncratic personality. Quentin Jacobsen, or Q as he is more commonly known, is close to graduating from high school. Friend to the band geeks, but not musical himself, his social group hovers towards the outer edges of the high school milieu. His next door neighbour is the queen-bee of the high school social world, Margo Roth Spiegelman, who he has been madly in love with since they were children. As children, they discovered a dead body in a local park but drifted apart over the years. Until one night, just a few weeks away from graduation, Margo appears at his window and lures him into a night of adventure of elaborate pranks and spirited youthful antics. The next day, she disappears.

It was life as it had always been — only more fatigued. I had hoped that last night would change my life, but it hadn’t — at least not yet.

Q is left behind with a series of clues, including highlighted passages of Walt Whitman’s “Song of Myself”, and induced by his all too brief contact with Margo, sets off to find her and discover who she really is. Until about halfway through I thought that Paper Towns was going to follow the same paths as Looking for Alaska and An Abundance of Katherines – and while all three novels have very similar storylines, Paper Towns diverges from the usage of a female character as the gateway to the male’s understanding of love, life and everything in between. While Q’s quest does have aspects of this, the combination of analysis of “Song of Myself” and Q’s unveiling of his illusions of Margo and lack of real understanding or knowledge of her as a person elevate Paper Towns to a increasingly complex self-referential piece of literature.

And all at once I knew how Margo Roth Spiegelman felt when she wasn’t being Margo Roth Spiegelman: she felt empty. She felt the unscaleable wall surrounding her. I thought of her asleep on the carpet with only that jagged sliver of sky above her. Maybe Margo felt comfortable there because Margo the person lived like that all the time: in an abandoned room with blocked-out windows, the only light pouring in through holes in the roof. Yes. The fundamental mistake I had always made — and that she had, in fairness, always led me to make — was this: Margo was not a miracle. She was not an adventure. She was not a fine and precious thing. She was a girl.

In discovering Margo, after an epic twenty-four hour road trip with his closest friends (and it must be mentioned that Green writes friendships so well), Q learns that a) she didn’t want to be found, and b) his illusions and his idealization of her does not match up to the “real” image of Margo Roth Spiegelman. This unequal distribution of images of a person isn’t unsettling to Q’s entire understanding of life, however, but offers him a lesson in the perception of the Other, and that ultimately reveals more about himself than it does about her. While Margo is an intriguing character, the novel is about Q’s revelation about perception and understanding, and it is written in such a beautifully simple and engaging manner, keenly aware of the growing pains of adolescence. Margo is used as the motivation that sets in motion Q’s mission to further self-awareness, but in a much more complex and satisfying way than Green’s previous novels.

I have so much more to say about this novel, but I think it is going to take several further readings before I really am able to articulate what I want to say. (And, incidentally, I think that someone with the knowledge and extreme patience with French psychoanalytical theory could write a killer Lacanian analysis of Paper Towns.) However, Paper Towns is a deeply insightful novel, with characters and issues that are easy to relate to, and, finally, a female character that is more complex than divining light for the slightly awkward male character.

The Basketball Diaries by Jim Carroll (1978)

The Basketball Diaries by Jim Carroll (1978)The Basketball Diaries features excerpts from musician, poet, and author Jim Carroll’s adolescent journals, kept from age thirteen to sixteen; a time where he acquired a nasty junk habit between committing petty crime, attending classes and playing basketball. Written in New York in the mid-1960s, there is the distinct intonation of baby Beat in Carroll’s rhythms and hip slang, but none of the energy or enlightenment. Rather, Carroll’s constant nodding out on heroin becomes repetitious to the point of boredom. The Basketball Diaries lacks the narcotic cadence of other drug-fuelled memoirs or prose, most likely due to the age of the author at the time of writing them.

You just got to see that junk is just another nine to five gig in the end, only the hours are a bit more inclined toward shadows.

Carroll’s descent into heroin begins when he starts shooting up under the mistaken belief that marijuana, not heroin, is the habit forming drug. Young Jim guides us through his journey toward and through (but not out of) his addiction and the risks he takes in order to get his fix. The beginning of the diaries start off innocently enough, his peers are his school and neighbourhood friends, they commit crime and take lighter drugs, engage in sometimes funny pranks, and the usual boyish behaviour you’d expect. It is only through comparison that we can see any evidence of the loss of innocence/childhood/faith (delete as appropriate), because Carroll himself doesn’t seem to want to expand upon this. It seems, through his bleary eyes, that the drug addiction is to be seen as something of a gain, an extension of himself, something that offers a better version of himself through the purer state of existence that he aims for.

Now there’s one set of gimmicks hid up there and it’s the filthiest spike you ever could see, been used by guys I prefer not to think of out of the fact my stomach is a bit upset. But you bet your ass there is not one bit of hesitation in drawing your shot into that harpoon and shoving it into your mainline. If you got dope you will get it inside you no matter how and I will too I can’t deny that. But here’s what I can’t get. Willie asks me for a slug of soda so I pass him the bottle and what the hell does he do but pull that old second grade bullshit of wiping off the top of the bottle before he takes some. Shit, I men anything I can give him from that bottle he’s gonna get a lot easier from using the same spike. None of these lames think twice, or once, in fact.

It’s difficult to feel any sympathy for Carroll, and he wouldn’t want it if we did. Though there are very few moments of inspired prose, Carroll jerking off on the roof under the stars and moon stands out as one instance of vivid imagery, the majority of The Basketball Diaries is tediously boring.

Cannery Row by John Steinbeck (1945)

Cannery Row by John Steinbeck (1945)Whenever I read a classic novel, or something by a renowned author, I stare blankly at the document in which I intend to write my review, deeply anxious and uncertain. “But, Cannery Row has been read by a million people before me, studied by thousands of students, what else can I possibly say about it?” Even though the act of reading the novel can be immensely pleasurable, when it comes to writing about it I freeze. I even considered rewriting the lyrics to Bob Dylan’s “Desolation Row” to reference Cannery Row (“Mack and the boys they’re restless/they need somewhere to go/as Doc and I look out tonight/from Cannery Row” it could work, I tell you.) in order to avoid actually talking about the book itself. (You have to wonder, what will I be like when I get around to that William Faulkner marathon I have planned? Interpretive dance review of The Sound and the Fury?)

Cannery Row in Monterey in California is a poem, a stink, a grating noise, a quality of light, a tone, a habit, a nostalgia, a dream. Cannery Row is the gathered and scattered, tin and iron and rust and splintered wood, chipped pavement and weedy lots and junk heaps, sardine canneries or corrugated iron, honky-tonks, restaurants and whore-houses, and little crowded groceries, and laboratories and flop-houses. Its inhabitants are, as the man once said, ‘whores, pimps, gamblers, and sons of bitches,’ by which he meant Everybody. Had the man looked through another peep-hole he might have said: ‘Saints and angels and martyrs and holy men,’ and he would have meant the same thing.

John Steinbeck‘s Cannery Row is set in the waterfront street known as Cannery Row in Monterey, California. Somehow, in the space of what is comparatively a novella, Steinbeck lets us into the worlds of a multitude of characters who reveal themselves to be more than our initial impressions of them and a testament to the necessity of community. The narrative is fractured between different characters as the poorer inhabitants of the street attempt to throw a party for Doc, a marine biologist who has offered much to the community. While the intention, led by the bums of the Palace Flophouse, is good, the follow through just doesn’t go quite to plan; but, the community eventually pulls together to throw a party that honours the kind-hearted Doc.

Within the narrative itself, Steinbeck – mainly through Doc’s observations of marine life, but also through the omniscient voice of the narrator – reflects on the natural world and how it reflects our own. Seemingly tranquil sea life proves to be capable of the the most vicious violence, the bums catching frogs for money is described with the detail of a bloody battlefield, a gopher builds a home in a safe area but cannot find a mate so moves on to a more dangerous area. The attention to these aspects of nature reveals life on the Row to be similarly delicate ecosystem.

Early morning is a time of magic in Cannery Row. In the grey time after the light has come and before the sun has risen, the Row seems to hang suspended out of time in a silvery light. The street lights go out, and the weeds are a brilliant green. The corrugated iron of the canneries glows with the pearly lucence of platinum or old pewter. No automobiles are running then. The street is silent of progress and business. And the rush and drag of the waves can be heard as they splash in among the piles of the canneries. It is a time of great peace, a deserted time, a little era of rest.

Despite the brevity of the text, the nuanced cast of characters and their stories feel complete. To add more to them would be going overboard. Steinbeck’s simplicity possesses an innate awareness of the aspects of these characters which make them a.) interesting to a reader and b.) integral to the Cannery Row hive. They may not be extraordinary people, but their talents, their humanity and their generosity lend them a dignity which cannot be denied. Dora, the madame of the Bear Flag brothel, sends her girls out to look after the children of the town when influenza strikes and the ill cannot afford medical assistance, despite it being the busiest time of year at the brothel. Lee Chong owns the grocery store, and though the locals owe him large amounts of money, he doesn’t chase it up – knowing that eventually they’ll repay him rather than trek to the market in the next town. Henri the local artists constantly builds and dismantles his boat, never wishing to complete it.

Financial bitterness could not eat too deeply into Mack and the boys, for they were not mercantile men. They did not measure their joy in goods sold, their egos in bank balances, nor their loves in what they cost.

After the first disastrous attempt to give Doc a party – to which he doesn’t even arrive, and great damage is inflicted upon his house – the street not only makes outcasts of the perpetrators; but begins to suffer itself. It’s as though if one part of this community is ill at ease, the whole community faces great misfortune. As Mack and the boys are gradually forgiven, the town heals, the illness and misfortune lifts. It’s a beautiful illusion, and it is impossible not to feel a deep yearning for a sense of community as deep and essential as is evident in Cannery Row. Does community like this exist anymore? Did it ever?

‘It has always seemed strange to me,’ said Doc. ‘The things we admire in men, kindness and generosity, openness, honesty, understanding, and feeling are the concomitants of failure in our system. And those traits we detest, sharpness, greed, acquisitiveness, meanness, egotism, and self-interest are the traits of success. And while men admire the quality of the first they love the produce of the second.’

Cannery Row is a deceptively simple story – the inhabitants of a street gather to throw a party for an honoured resident – but the heart and the faith in humanity that Steinbeck imbues this story with is amazing, and difficult to forget. Celebration of good deeds and genial warmth are essential to the proliferation of the human spirit, and despite their lack of ambition or lofty pursuits, and in this the folks of Cannery Row are richer than most. Sweet Thursday is a sequel set years after the events in Cannery Row, although I will be trying to get a copy soon, I think I’ll let the pleasures of Cannery Row linger a little while longer.

Book Loot: Week Ending 14th March, 2010

Virginia Frances Sterret, frontispiece to Old French Fairy Tales, by the Comtesse de Ségur. Philadelphia, 1920Remember a few months ago I was quite taken with a short story called “Jeane” by James Hopkin? Well, this week I found his debut novel, Winter Under Water,  in the the most unexpected of places. It was a remainder outlet in the city, which had an upstairs area where the books were priced 10 for $10 or $5 each. Of course I went up there and had a look around, but the place itself felt eerily quiet in the midst of the bustling metropolis. There wasn’t much to entice me, but I did find Winter Under Water and Susanna Moore’s In the Cut.

I took the past few days off, an internet sabbatical perhaps you could call it. Maybe it’s just me, but every so often the internet just becomes just too much and I feel myself going slightly screwy with information overload, to the point where it feels like the only possible release is a Scanners style explosion. However, the best remedy is usually to turn off the computer, remove myself from most, if not all, online services, and take some time to rejuvenate. If I were rich, this would probably involve expensive day spas and intensive massages by attractive young men;  instead I’ve just hung out with my Dad, worked (a surprisingly effective way to boost my self-confidence) and caught up on some (offline) reading.

In the time before deciding to take some time off the internet, I did come across some interesting links which might, if you’re not already suffering from hyper-information related illness, also be of interest to you.

[image credit: Virginia Frances Sterret, frontispiece to Old French Fairy Tales, by the Comtesse de Ségur. Philadelphia, 1920, via archive.org, found via Old Book Illustrations]

Hoax Nation: Australian Fakes and Frauds from Plato to Norma Khouri by Simon Caterson (2009)

Hoax Nation: Australian Fakes and Frauds from Plato to Norma Khouri (2009)Hoax Nation: Australian Fakes and Frauds from Plato to Norma Khouri is a refreshingly different look at the variety of hoaxes perpetrated throughout the annals of Australian history. Rather than recount our colourful history through the usual method of what we have deem truth, Simon Caterson takes a look at the events, publications, and cultural ephemera that were discovered to be elaborate hoaxes. As the subtitle suggests, the history of Australia has always been marked by misunderstandings and falsified accounts, and Caterson relishes in reviving these historical deceptions. A selection of quotations from everyone from Marcel Proust to Matt Damon on the art of the lie or the fallibility of truth adds an extra dimension to the work.

What I appreciated about Hoax Nation was the breadth of topics covered, however the limitations of space in Arcade’s signature small sized books meant that some foundational information was left out, leaving this particularly ignorant reader to seek out more about the Ern Malley affair and Bodyline scandal in order to better understand the hoaxed material related to them. Nonetheless, Hoax Nation works as a brilliant starting point for the reverse side of the official Australian history. Covering the famous literary hoaxes of Norma Khouri and Helen Demidenko which played to cultural perceptions and caused debate about the accountability of publishers, it seems that for every hoax that was executed for fame, fortune and glory, there were many that worked on a multitude of levels.

It certainly seems as though hoaxes originate in response to a demand, or are created to fill a perceived gap in culture (in the 1980s and 90s there’s little doubt the advent of multiculturalism coincided with a proliferation of ethnic and indigenous identity frauds in the arts, especially literature – impostors, in particular, flourish when we regard the background and identity of the singer as being as important as the song). And in the heat of the battle, whether the conflict is over politics, culture, history, science or religion, truth is often the first casualty and hoaxes can appear on any side.

While many of the hoaxes seem to have been carried out for the sheer joy of mischief, many including the curious case of George Barrington, appear to have been committed for more politically motivated reasons. A pickpocket sent to the convict colony of Australia in the late 18th century, a number of best-selling books telling of the imagined life in the new colony were published under Barrington’s name. Known as something of a celebrity criminal in England, the move to Australia saw Barrington eventually become a police superintendent, and supposedly, halt a potential mutiny on the journey over. Largely plagiarized from other sources – and yet still quoted today as legitimate historical sources! – there is little to suggest that Barrington actually wrote the stories. Nonetheless, the books not only whet the appetite for tales from Australia and narratives of convict life, but also as proof, as it were, that criminal reformation in the antipodes was a successful endeavour.

Hoax Nation: Australian Fakes and Frauds from Plato to Norma Khouri features a wide array of hoaxes – from art, literature, fauna, landscape, and Australian legends – bursting with fascination and a salute to the numerous bullshit artists who have peppered our history with intrigue and humour. Not always merely for the fun of deception, many of these hoaxes force us to ask important questions about identity, about authenticity and about our preconceived cultural perceptions.

[Disclaimer: publisher supplied copy, with thanks to the team at Arcade Publications. For my reviews of other Arcade titles, please see: Madame Brussels: This Moral Pandemonium, E.W. Cole: Chasing the Rainbow and Our Girls: Aussie Pin-Ups of the 40s and 50s.]