An Eye on Carson McCullers: November 2010

“Member of the Wedding”, Opening Night, Ethel Waters, Carson McCullers and Julie Harris, New York City 1950 by Ruth OrkinA compilation of Carson McCullers news, tidbits and mere mentions from around the Internet in November, 2010. In other words, I sift through the spam and pointless mentions to bring you the monthly CMcC gold.

Photo: “Member of the Wedding”, Opening Night, Ethel Waters, Carson McCullers and Julie Harris, New York City 1950 by Ruth Orkin. I love this photograph so much.

An Eye on Carson McCullers: October 2010

Marilyn Monroe, Carson McCullers & Isak Dinesen, February 1959A compilation of Carson McCullers news, tidbits and mere mentions from around the Internet in October, 2010:

Anything I missed? Let me and other McCullers fans know in the comments.

I’ll Give You a Nickel & Dance You a Jig: Sweet as a Pickle and Clean as a Pig by Carson McCullers (1964)

Sweet as a Pickle and Clean as a Pig by Carson McCullers (1964)As I mentioned in a recent Book Loot post, I recently bought a copy of McCullers’ rare book of children’s verse from 1964 Sweet as a Pickle and Clean as a Pig. There doesn’t seem to be much on the web about it, other than the fact that it exists. Most of the copies on AbeBooks go for at least $100 Australian, and while I do obviously love McCullers, I just couldn’t afford to shell out that much for one highly collectable book. Nonetheless, I kept a regular lookout for copies for sale and with some nifty searching skills, thanks to my library services course, came across a copy that was listed as “Clean as a Nut” rather than Pig and much cheaper than other copies so I snapped it up. I didn’t expect the quality to be too great for the price I got it for, I thought maybe it would be an ex-library copy or significantly damaged but when it arrived it was pretty much in perfect condition! A very lucky find.

These are children’s rhymes so there isn’t the same level of depth of human understanding here, but McCullers seemed to, even in her later years, have a firm grasp on the curiousity of childhood. Many of the poems are ponderous, sort of like a child-like daydream about the contradictions of the world, like, wondering who on earth put the “D” in Wednesday or if Santa will miss a friend’s house because he doesn’t have a chimney? Some of these poems even retain the strong connection and sense of the American South and family, such as in “Olden Times” when a child listens to her mother speak about her childhood. Seasonal events are given just as much importance as the everyday. There’s an understanding, even here, of the misfits, such as in the tale of the naughtiest boy in school Sport Williams:

Oh! Sport was a bad boy.
No one loved him but his mother.
And when he was suspended, she said “He was not
A bad boy,
But a sad boy…” because
No one loved him but her, his mother.

This is, and this is a completely biased opinion, a lovely little collection of childlike rhymes. The illustrations by Rolf Gérard are charming, black and white crayon styled drawings with splashes of orange or green. My favourite poem of all from Sweet as a Pickle and Clean as a Pig is “Song for a Sailor” which I think fits in so well with McCullers’ oeuvre, it covers imagination and love, the disparity between reality and imagined perceptions – though maybe not as beautifully expressed as in her fiction, the simplicity shows the same childlike, outsider point of view that we’ve come to associate so strongly with McCullers.

Song for a Sailor
I’ve never seen the ocean,
I’ve never seen the sea,
But once I loved a sailor,
And that’s good enough for me.

While Sweet as a Pickle and Clean as a Pig may not be an essential book for understanding McCullers and her writing, it is a genuinely lovely and simple book of poems, sure to evoke pangs of nostalgia in anyone.

http://www.walkingoffthebigapple.com/2010/10/advantages-of-new-perspective-literary.html

An Eye on Carson McCullers: September 2010

Carson McCullers and Edward AlbeeTo break from the routine of constant book reviews, here’s a round up of Carson McCullers news and points of interest for the month of September.

Photo credit: Carson McCullers and Edward Albee, from the Billy Rose Theatre Collection at the New York Public Library Digital Gallery.

Book Loot: Week Ending May 23rd, 2010

Ernest Hemingway poses with a water buffalo while on safari in Africa, 1953-1954Well, it appears after last week’s overload of links the internet has dried up this week. It’s good, in a way, as I seem to have been a lot more productive this week. Thanks boring internet, but please don’t always be this way. Oh look! Here’s Ernest Hemingway with a buffalo!

Photo credit: Ernest Hemingway poses with a water buffalo while on safari in Africa, 1953-1954. Photograph in the Ernest Hemingway Photograph Collection, John F. Kennedy Presidential Library, Boston.

http://thenewinquiry.com/post/589628505/lester-bangs-and-rock-music-as-the-eternal-high-school

Book Loot: Week Ending May 9th, 2010

The Debutantes by Marta Aronssohn-Danzig (c1889)A few more of my Fitzgerald set have been arriving this week, only a couple more due in and then I’ve completed my whole set and sense of fulfillment and happiness will surely follow.

And, a whole bunch of links of good reading for you all.

Picture credit: The Debutantes by Marta Aronssohn-Danzig (c1889); nothing to do with anything, really, I just like the look on their faces: “really Jess?, you’re talking about Carson McCullers again? Sigh.”

Book Loot: Week Ending 28th February, 2010

John WatersCan you believe February is already over? It feels like only yesterday I was ringing in the new year with some bad singing and even worse dancing. The summer is over, March is upon us. This past week has been insanely busy, with live music protests, Wheeler Centre events, a music festival and associated sideshows, and, possibly my favourite, seeing the fabulous and funny film director John Waters deliver a monologue last night at Hamer Hall about all things filthy. He has a book due out later this year, Role Models, and excerpts are already available online. Waters spoke all too briefly about his extensive book collection – art books and film novelizations his specialty – and offered his sage and perennial advice:

If you go home with somebody and they don’t have books, don’t fuck ‘em.

This week another of the Carson McCullers‘ set I’ve started collecting arrived from France, this week it was Clock Without Hands, which of course I reviewed a few weeks ago. As I mentioned, the covers are of a simple typographical design, with a large black and white photograph of McCullers on the back flap of the dust jacket. Along with the most recent Penguin Modern Classic editions of her works, these hardcovers are probably the most appealing I’ve seen, I’ll be sure to post more photos of them once the collection expands.

Book Loot: Week Ending February 21st, 2010

Book Loot: Week Ending 21st February, 2010It seems a fitting end to Carson McCullers Week 2010 that this week’s loot includes a McCullers book. I’ve discovered a British publisher that re-released her novels with the release of the Mortgaged Heart in the early 1970s, and they all have classic typographical hardcovers. And so, in typical obsessive mode, I’m working on collecting myself a complete set, starting with The Heart is a Lonely Hunter, with Clock Without Hands [review] making its way to me from France, and pining for the rest of them.

I even had the first pick of a huge box full of outdated trade proofs at work and only came home with E.L. Doctorow’s Homer and Langley. I think my attitude to book buying/hoarding has shifted, I’m just not sure when/why/how this shift occurred. Working in the bookstore hasn’t weakened my resolve, the only books I’ve bought there so far have been as presents for others. Although I do have my eye and heart eagerly set on a delicious looking Penguin reference box set.

Simon Caterson’s Hoax Nation: Australian Fakes and Frauds, from Plato to Norma Khouri is a review copy kindly sent from Arcade Publications, and I’m really looking forward to getting stuck into it. They also sent me their Melbourne by the Book pamphlet of “Literary Hot Spots, Bookstores, Festivals and More” which is going to give me a lot of new bookish places to explore around town, giving me approximately 451283 more reasons to love Melbourne.

In addition to these new reads, I’ve also been borrowing from the library a lot. And I really mean a lot. I’m too embarrassed to post a photo of exactly what I have borrowed over the past week or so because it displays the sheer audacity of my ambitious approach to reading. I’ve got some young adult fiction, a lot of books by authors from the Gala Night last week, and some books I’ve just haven’t yet gotten around to reading or have found impossible  to find elsewhere. It’s almost daunting, it would be impossible for anyone to read the stupid amounts of books I have out on loan, but goddamnit if I’m not going to try.

Short Story Soiree: Sucker by Carson McCullers (1963)

The Mortgaged Heart by Carson McCullers (1972)The Short Story Soiree is back after a short break last week due to my time getting gobbled up by other commitments. Incidentally, this also marks the 100th post on Start Narrative Here, and it’s kind of nice to have a milestone post take place within a week dedicated to my favourite author. In The Mortgaged Heart, Margarita Smith argues that these shorter pieces of McCullers’ writing are examples of early writing exercises rather than fully formed stories. “Sucker” was published in the Saturday Evening Post in 1963, but it is believed that Carson wrote it when she was about seventeen. Included in the documentation of The Mortgaged Heart is a rejection letter dated 1939 listing the twenty six publications that rejected two of McCullers short stories, “Sucker” included.

The Sucker of this short story is the younger orphaned cousin of the narrator, Pete, who share a room together. Pete at sixteen is just beginning to become interested in girls, specifically the coiffed and manicured Maybelle, while Sucker at twelve is a quiet and timid boy who idolizes Pete. Sucker tries to bond with Pete, but Pete is too preoccupied with the perpetually aloof Maybelle. Mimicking Maybelle’s own rejection of Pete, Pete belittles and ignores Sucker and his feelings. Written from Pete’s perspective after the major change in their relationship, he is remorseful over his treatment of Sucker, but aware that he is unable to take any of it back.

Now that Sucker has changed so much it is a little hard to remember him as he used to be. I never imagined anything would suddenly happen that would make us both very different. I never knew that in order to get what has happened straight in my mind I would want to think back on him as he used to be and compare and try to get things settled. If I could have seen him ahead maybe I would have acted different.

As Maybelle starts to pay more attention to Pete, so too does Pete to Sucker. One evening, awakened from the bliss of a dream of kissing Maybelle, Sucker asks Pete if he likes him as much as a brother. Pete responds positively, even calling Sucker “a swell kid.” In this moment Pete realizes that he actually does really like Sucker, probably even more than he likes Maybelle, and they begin to grow closer. As the fluctuating desires of Maybelle turn against Pete, Pete too rages against Sucker, taking out his frustrations on the only person he can. As Pete repeatedly and brutally hurls out insults and insinuates that Sucker is unwanted, something changes in Sucker, a change is visible to Pete even as it is happening. Sucker is never quite the same afterward, a hardness comes into his face, and he retreats. Pete too is changed by this event, but has no way of altering his past behaviour.

More than anything I want to be easy in my mind again. And I miss the way Sucker and I were for a while in a funny, sad way that before this I never would have believed. But everything is so different that there seems to be nothing I can do to get it right. I’ve sometimes thought if we could have it out in a big fight that would help. But I can’t fight him because he’s four years younger. And another thing – sometimes this look in his eyes makes me almost believe that if Sucker could he would kill me.

It’s pretty wrenching stuff, the loss of innocence and faith in other people at such a young age. Disappointments from those who you hold highest always sting the most. Pete’s callous lashing out at Sucker causes irreparable damage to their relationship; and Pete recognizes that his harsh treatment of Sucker is unforgivable. It’s not my favourite McCullers short story (that easily goes to “A Tree, A Rock, A Cloud” which I could probably quite easily spend an entire week talking about), but “Sucker” hits a nerve because of the sensitive treatment of youthful disappointments.

[Also, when I was younger and learning to talk I couldn't pronounce my name - Jessica - properly and so called myself "Sucker." As in Jes-sucker, get it? It's for the best the nickname hasn't stuck beyond the occasional use from immediate family members.]

Clock Without Hands by Carson McCullers (1961)

Clock Without Hands by Carson McCullers (1961)Clock Without Hands, Carson McCullers‘ final novel, is permeated by a sense of illness, death and social disease. Set in a small town in the South of the United States, circling the lives of four very different men, two young, two old, their lives collide in the present and in the past in a series of violent, unsettling confrontations. Bleak and despondent as it is, McCullers imbues this darkness with an understanding of the fragility of the human heart, the futile rage against death and the necessity of the fight against social injustice.

The novel opens with J.T. Malone, the local pharmacist, discovering that he is suffering from leukemia and only has a few months to live. A mostly virtuous man, he begins to question and lash out at the world which offers him no hope, no cure and no redemption. He considers his life differently knowing that he has not much time left to live it. He maintains a somewhat close friendship with the larger than life figure of Judge Fox Clane. Excessive in opinion, body and stature, but with his mind succumbing to the senility of old age and having suffered a stroke which paralyzed half his body and dealing with diabetes, the Judge continually denies any evidence of illness to all outsiders. His wife’s death left a considerable gap in his life, and he tries to fill it with other women, women with similar habits or looks, only to find them all unsatisfactory. Having lost his only son to suicide, the Judge’s only relation is the idealistic and sensitive Jester Clane.

Several months ago he had read in these bylines the words: ‘How can the dead truly be dead when they are still walking in my heart?’ It was from an old Indian legend and the Judge could not forget it.

Jester’s relationship with his grandfather is bristling with their conflicting opinions over the issue of race. While the Judge longs for the old days of the South, Jester antagonizes him with his desire for full integration. Despite the Judge’s racist attitudes, his closest relationship is with his amanuensis, the blue-eyed black boy Sherman Pew. An orphan who is constantly searching for his unknown mother, and desperately seeking her in musical stars, Sherman is prickly to everyone that is around him. Nonetheless, he and Jester share a friendly competitiveness and antagonism which often becomes humiliating to both. Jester, it is suggested, harbours deeper feelings for Sherman.

Not only are their current lives and situations delicately intertwined, but as the novel moves along and revelations are made, their pasts are just as connected. Jester’s discovery of his father’s personality and circumstances before his suicide through the late night hysterics of the Judge answers the vital questions of identity for him, whereas Sherman’s own acknowledgment of his parentage only leads to more questions and his sense of self utterly destroyed. It is these questions and uncertainty that lead him to take action against the racist implications of the town, which in turn leads to the horrifically violent confrontation that ends in his death. Meanwhile, Malone, gradually closer to his death, stands up to his townsfolk and refuses their intense appetite for destruction in the name of morality, making his final grasp at heroism. Though he doesn’t achieve it in the eyes of the betrayed, hurt townspeople, he comes closer to peace with himself and the world around him.

As he sat holding the pestle there was in him enough composure to wonder at those alien emotions that had veered so violently in his once mild heart. He was split between love and hatred – but what he loved and what he hated was unclear. For the first time he knew that death was near him. But the terror that choked him was not caused by the knowledge of his own death. The terror concerned some mysterious drama that was going on – although what the drama was about Malone did not know. The terror questioned what would happen in those months – how long? – that glared upon his numbered days. He was a man watching a clock without hands.

The most somber detail of the novel is the profound sense of the failure of traditional spiritual or religious modes to explain death or to offer comfort to the dying. The Judge freely moves from church to church, mainly hoping to find someone who can mimic his dead wife than to find solace in religion; Malone too looks for comfort in the church but fails to find it, and yet refuses to commit the act of violence because he doesn’t want to endanger his soul. Redemption is made on earth, in humane actions, but Malone seeks justification for it in the sacred.

Yes, the earth had revolved its seasons and spring had come again. but there was no longer a revulsion against nature, against things. A strange lightness had come upon his soul and he exalted. He looked at nature now and it was part of himself. He was no longer a man watching a clock without hands. He was not alone, he did not rebel, he did not suffer. He did not even think of death these days. He was not a man dying – nobody died, everybody died.

As in all of McCullers’ novels, Clock Without Hands seeks to explore the injustices of society, spiritual isolation and confusion, the confounding nature of human love and affection, our own battles with ourselves prying us apart from those around us. Yet, as bleak as the issues it deals with are, one doesn’t leave the vivid world of Clock Without Hands feeling weighed down by the impotence of our struggle against death, but rather with the intimation that hope is always available at all junctures of life, even on the very cusp of death.

Poem: Saraband by Carson McCullers

The Mortgaged Heart by Carson McCullers (1972)Though primarily known as a writer of novels and plays, Carson McCullers did also write a little poetry. She even published a book of children’s verse, Sweet as a Pickle, Clean as a Pig, which I believe was only given one print run and seems to be rather scarce today. There are always a few copies on AbeBooks, but always just that little bit out of my price range, perhaps one day I will treat myself to my own copy. Until then, a very small selection of her poetry is available in the posthumous collection of her writing edited by her sister, Margarita G. Smith, The Mortgaged Heart. All of the poetry published in this volume is also available online. The anecdote from Margarita Smith refers to “Stone is Not Stone

This poem called ‘Saraband’ was recorded for MGM records for Carson McCullers Reads (one day I will get that record converted), although McCullers was reciting her poems from memory and forgot four of the lines. I love how appropriately musical the rhythm of this piece is, especially when read aloud. It’s so rhythmic and soothing, especially with couplets such as the darkly beautiful “crown a host of unassorted sorrows/you never could manage one by one”, which reminds me of Elliott Smith lyrics.

Carson McCullers by Carl Van Vechten, 1959

Saraband

Select your sorrows if you can,
Edit your ironies, even grieve with guile.
Adjust to a world divided
Which demands your candid senses stoop to labyrinthine wiles
What natural alchemy lends
To the scrubby grocery boy with dirty hair
The lustre of Apollo, or Golden Hyacinth’s fabled stare.
If you must cross the April park, be brisk:
Avoid the cadence of the evening, eyes from afar
Lest you be held as a security risk
Solicit only the evening star.

Your desperate nerves fuse laughter with disaster
And higgledy piggledy giggle once begun
Crown a host of unassorted sorrows
You never could manage one by one.
The world that jibes your tenderness
Jails your lust.
Bewildered by the paradox of all your musts
Turning from horizon to horizon, noonday to dusk:
It may be only you can understand:
On a mild sea afternoon of blue and gold
When the sky is a mild blue of a Chinese bowl
The bones of Hart Crane, sailors and the drugstore man
Beat on the ocean’s floor the same saraband.

About her poetry, I remember best one evening at a university lecture. After she had recited ‘Stone Is Not Stone’ in her gentle Southern voice, there was a long silence. Then suddenly a young student stood up and said, ‘Mrs McCullers, I love you.’
(Margarita Smith on Carson McCullers’ poetry in The Mortgaged Heart)

[Photo Credit: Carson McCullers in 1959, by Carl Van Vechten from the Library of Congress collection]